The real Naughty and Nice list by Nicole Lutz

Posted by on

Christmas is just around the corner, and Oxfam has released their annual Naughty or Nice List. Established in 2013, after the Rana Plaza factory collapse, Oxfam  directs consumers towards brands whom, according to their own media release, “have made a real commitment to paying a living wage.

As a conscientious consumer, I don’t want to fill my shopping cart with Christmas gifts made by modern slaves. As a writer who has frequented the sustainable fashion scene for several years, I feel immediately sceptical over most of the companies who made the nice list. Even by Oxfam’s own reporting, none of these brands pays living wages. To settle the matter once and for all, I decided to investigate what it takes to make the nice list.

According to Oxfam Australia Labour Rights Lead, Sarah Rogan, “Brands on Oxfam’s nice list – including Kmart, Cotton On, Bonds, Gorman and David Jones – have made commitments that included a clear and appropriate definition of a living wage, and at least two or three key milestones and timelines to reach those significant steps.”

In my critical interpretation, this means: highly-profitable brands with big marketing budgets can pledge to change their ways, within a specific time frame, and receive free PR in exchange for their words. And they don’t even have to follow through.

Let’s consider the example of H&M, a Swedish retail label worth an estimated US$29.7 billion dollars. H&M repeatedly feature on Oxfam’s nice list, because they pledged to pay garment workers a living wage within five years. That was in 2013, after the Rana Plaza tragedy. Fast-forward six years to 2019, and H&M still don’t pay living wages. Instead, they have changed their policy, revised their pledge and set new targets, ticking Oxfam’s “key milestones and timelines” targets to warrant the “nice” label. 

Theoretically, I understand that it takes time to make changes within big businesses. I also understand the logic behind Oxfam pursuing this list as a way to separate those who have made some effort, from those who have done nothing. And I’m sure Oxfam feel just like a weary parent who has to praise the most beige efforts, hoping it will set the landscape for improved behaviours sometime in the future. So truly, I empathise with the complexities of the bigger picture. But the reality is that this list is misleading and ultimately damaging to supply chain workers. Why? At the risk of sounding repetitive, none of Oxfam’s nice list pays living wages.

Oxfam’s own media release ,that accompanies their naughty or nice list, emphasises the necessity of a living wage, yet they fail to publicly recognise those who already pay it:

"A living wage means enough money is earned in a standard week to cover basic essentials including food, housing, healthcare, clothing, transport, education and some money for unexpected events."

"A living wage is not a luxury, but is a minimum that all working people should be paid if they are to escape the cycle of poverty," Ms Rogan said.

Across Australia, and indeed the world, incredible small businesses are working hard to create products with minimal harm to people or the planet. They don’t have big budgets to spend on marketing or PR, yet they’re most worthy of the free publicity that Oxfam’s naughty or nice list provides. 

These brands who pay living wages are the select few who receive an A+ rating in the ethical fashion report. They don’t talk about creating social change or set targets in the future because they already do the right thing now. These are the brands that deserve to be on everyone's list this Christmas:

*Mighty Good Group ceased production earlier this year, though their products are still available online in limited supplies.

Outside of these A+ scoring companies, I encourage every one of you to seek gifts from Fairtrade certified companies, as well as local artisans and creators. There are incredibly talented individuals making children’s toys, clothing, homewares and accessories right on your doorstep. They’re at your local market, selling wares online, and they do it all without causing harm to others. Shopping for good-quality secondhand gifts is also a completely reasonable and ethical form of giving, as are experience-based gifts.

While I understand the complex and intense desire to give gifts at Christmas time, and I appreciate it is a habit ingrained and reinforced over a lifetime: it doesn’t have to be this way. Rather than wandering through shopping centres guided by a warped perception of what’s naughty or nice, think twice. Support the brands who are doing the right thing now.

← Older Post Newer Post →

Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published

How much is:


★ Customer Reviews ★

Let customers speak for us

652 reviews
In love!

These are hands down my favourite thongs! I've always worn Havaianas but I'm trying to make better choices by shopping ethically and sustainably and I'm very happy to have found these as a replacement. When I first wore them one did leave a little sore on the top of my foot, but whatever was causing that friction seemed to wear off fairly quick so I don't think it's a common or problematic issue, and certainly nothing a bandaid while breaking in can't fix. I think the print is really cute as well, I usually like to keep things simple and pick all black but the print on these always makes me feel a little better when I put them on. Very happy with my purchase and will definitely continue to choose these over any other brand!

Unisex Navy Crew Neck Organic Fairtrade
Sophia Holden (Adelaide, AU)

Lovely fit and feel to the fabric

Unisex Charcoal T-shirt Organic Fairtrade
Mitzi Galant (Wellington, NZ)

All great, except 3 x tags seems too much

I Like This Hoodie

I've worn it every day since it arrived. It's very comfy.

Bikini, Black, Organic & Fairtrade
Karin at Tinkerwell (Melbourne, AU)

These undies are simply fantastic! Comfortable and soft. Reassuring to know both workers and environment are being treated with care and respect too.

Net Orders Checkout

Item Price Qty Total
Subtotal $0.00

Shipping Address

Shipping Methods